Walk into a running shop asking whether you should go barefoot or cushioned and you will hear two confident stories. One says modern cushioning weakens the foot and causes injuries. The other says thin shoes overload the foot and cause injuries. The published evidence is far less dramatic than either story.
Cushioned shoes have not been shown to prevent running injuries, and minimalist shoes have not been shown to prevent them either. What the research does show is that the change is the risky part: switching to minimal shoes too quickly increases bone stress in the foot, and the runners who do best either transition slowly or rotate between pairs.
Quick answers
- Habitually barefoot runners usually land on the forefoot and habitually shod runners usually land on the heel, and the collision forces differ in shape (Lieberman et al., 2010). Landing pattern is not the same thing as injury rate.
- A systematic review of 23 studies found no definitive conclusions about the risks or benefits of barefoot or minimalist running, because the evidence quality was low to moderate (Perkins et al., 2014).
- In a 10-week switch to minimalist shoes, 10 of 19 runners developed bone marrow edema in the foot, against 1 of 17 controls, and 2 had stress fractures (Ridge et al., 2013).

The rest of the answers
- A 26-week trial found no significant difference in injury rates (37% versus 52%, p = .24) but more knee, shin, calf and ankle pain in minimalist shoes as mileage rose (Knapik et al., 2021).
- A 2026 meta-analysis of transition studies found the switch itself carries a moderate increase in injury risk, and suggests at least 12 weeks of progressive, supervised adaptation (Sánchez-Del Río et al., 2026).
Does the shoe change how you land?
Yes, at least in the lab. Lieberman and colleagues (2010) compared habitually barefoot and habitually shod runners in Kenya and the United States using force plates and high-speed video. Habitually barefoot runners mostly landed on the forefoot or midfoot; habitually shod runners mostly landed on the heel, which the raised, cushioned heel of a modern shoe makes easy.
In the same study, barefoot forefoot strikers generated smaller collision forces than shod heel strikers, even on hard surfaces. That finding is real and repeatable. It is also narrower than it sounds: the volunteers were people who had run barefoot or in minimal shoes for years, not runners who had just changed shoes. The study measured forces during a few strides on a track. It did not follow anyone long enough to count injuries.
That gap matters, because it is where most shoe arguments go wrong. A different force profile is not automatically a lower injury rate.
Do cushioned shoes make injuries worse?
No study has shown that. What studies show is that cushioning changes with wear, and that runners adapt to it without appearing to notice.
In a study by Kong and colleagues (2009), 24 runners ran 200 miles (about 322 km) in the same pair of shoes, then repeated the same lab tests in new and worn versions of three cushioning technologies. Cushioning fell with wear, yet peak vertical forces and loading rates stayed about the same. The runners changed how they landed, keeping the load roughly constant.
The systematic review by Perkins and colleagues (2014) reached a similar end point from the other direction. It found moderate evidence for biomechanical differences between barefoot and shod running, and concluded that no definitive statement could be made about the risks or benefits of either, because the available studies were not strong enough.

Do minimalist shoes reduce injuries?
Not convincingly. The trials that exist point in both directions, and the more carefully they are pooled, the less the shoe type seems to matter.
Warne and Gruber (2017) reviewed 20 transition studies and pooled injury counts: 17.9 injuries per 100 participants while transitioning to minimal footwear, against 13.4 per 100 in conventional shoes. That difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.219). The review did find more knee and calf pain during a six-month transition, particularly in runners going beyond about 35 km a week, and a higher injury risk in runners above 71.4 kg (hazard ratio 2.00, 95% CI 1.10 to 3.66).
Knapik and colleagues (2021) summarised a 26-week trial of 30 runners in conventional shoes and 31 in minimalist shoes, with exposure increasing by 5% of training time each week. After six weeks, at about 35% of training time in the new shoes, running economy was better and 5 km times were faster in the minimalist group. There was no further gain from week 6 to week 26. Injuries were 37% in the conventional group and 52% in the minimalist group, a difference that did not reach significance. Knee, shin, calf and ankle pain were higher in the minimalist group, and risk rose with body weight.
| Study | What it measured | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Lieberman et al., 2010 (Nature) | Landing pattern and collision forces, habitually barefoot vs shod | Forefoot landing and smaller collision forces in habitual barefoot runners |
| Perkins et al., 2014 (systematic review) | 23 studies on risk and benefit | No definitive conclusion; evidence quality low to moderate |
| Ridge et al., 2013 (MRI study) | Foot bone stress during a 10-week transition | 10 of 19 minimalist runners vs 1 of 17 controls developed bone marrow edema; 2 stress fractures |
| Warne & Gruber, 2017 (review of 20 studies) | Transition methods and injury counts | 17.9 vs 13.4 injuries per 100 participants, not significant; more knee and calf pain |
| Knapik et al., 2021 (26-week trial summary) | Injury, pain and performance, 30 vs 31 runners | Injury 37% vs 52% (p = .24); more leg pain with minimalist shoes |
| Sánchez-Del Río et al., 2026 (meta-analysis) | 12 transition studies, 313 participants | Moderate increase in injury risk during transition |
What actually gets hurt during a switch, and why?
The foot. Ridge and colleagues (2013) took MRI scans of 36 experienced runners before and after 10 weeks. Nineteen gradually moved part of their mileage into Vibram FiveFingers; 17 stayed in their usual shoes. Afterwards, 10 of the 19 minimalist runners showed increased bone marrow edema in at least one foot bone, against 1 of 17 controls. Two of the minimalist runners had stress fractures; none of the controls did.
The pattern has a mechanical explanation. A forefoot landing removes load from the heel and puts more of it through the metatarsals and the ankle, and it asks more of the calf and Achilles. That is why the injuries reported across transition studies cluster in the metatarsals, the Achilles and the calf rather than the knee.
None of this means forefoot landing is wrong. It means a foot that has spent years in cushioned shoes has not built the tolerance that the change demands, and bone adapts more slowly than the training plan usually allows.
How should a transition be run?
Slowly, and with a way to measure it. The 2026 meta-analysis concluded that supervised retraining programmes of at least 12 weeks may support adaptation and reduce risk. Warne and Gruber found that the 20 studies they reviewed ended with an average of 60% of running time in minimal shoes, ranging from 30% to 100%, and that only 8 of the 20 included any injury-prevention exercises.
A practical version, built from those protocols, looks like this:
- Weeks 1 to 2: one or two short runs a week in the new shoes, 1 to 2 km each, everything else in your usual pair.
- Weeks 3 to 6: add a short run, and keep total time in minimal shoes under roughly 35% of weekly running, the ceiling the 26-week trial settled on.
- Weeks 7 to 12: lengthen the minimal-shoe runs only if the foot, Achilles and calf have stayed quiet for two weeks at the previous step.
- After 12 weeks: decide by comfort, not by ideology. Many runners end up keeping most mileage in familiar shoes and using the thin pair for short, easy or technique-focused runs.
Cleveland Clinic gives the same advice in simpler form for any new pair: short walks first, alternate old and new for one to two weeks, increase weekly mileage by no more than 10%, and watch for new pain in the Achilles, arch or forefoot.

Who should probably not switch?
The evidence points to a few groups who gain little and risk more:
- Runners with a recent bone stress injury, who are rebuilding tolerance in the same bones the change loads most.
- Runners above about 71 kg, where the transition review found a doubled injury risk (hazard ratio 2.00).
- Runners logging more than about 35 km a week, where knee and calf pain rose during a six-month transition.
- Anyone who cannot hold the plan for 12 weeks, such as during a race build or a period of travel and irregular training.
Runners who already run in minimal shoes, who have no current pain, and who can add exposure in small steps are the ones the protocols were designed for.
So which shoe should you buy?
For most people, the answer is not a category but a pair that fits and a plan that changes slowly. If your goal is fewer injuries, the evidence puts more weight on training load, sleep, previous injury and gradual progression than on the height of the midsole.
If you are curious about minimal shoes, treat them as a second pair and a 12-week project, not a replacement. If you are happily running in cushioned shoes without pain, there is no evidence that switching would help you, and a real risk that a fast switch would set you back.
When to see a clinician instead of a shoe shop
Seek medical advice promptly if you have:
- Pain in one small spot of a foot bone that is getting sharper, especially with hopping or pressing
- Pain at rest or at night, or pain that keeps you from walking normally
- Swelling or bruising that is not settling after a few days
- A sudden pop or snap with immediate loss of push-off
- Numbness, tingling or unusual coldness in the foot
- Pain that has not improved after two weeks of easier running
Related Articles
- Plantar Fasciitis: Why Heel Pain Hits First Steps
- Achilles Tendinopathy: Heel-Back Pain and What Helps
- Shin Splints in Runners: Load, Rehab and Warning Signs
Sources
- Lieberman DE, Venkadesan M, Werbel WA, et al. Foot strike patterns and collision forces in habitually barefoot versus shod runners. Nature. 2010;463:531-535. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature08723
- Ridge ST, Johnson AW, Mitchell UH, et al. Foot bone marrow edema after a 10-wk transition to minimalist running shoes. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2013. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0b013e3182874769
- Perkins KP, Hanney WJ, Rothschild CE. The risks and benefits of running barefoot or in minimalist shoes: a systematic review. Sports Health. 2014. https://doi.org/10.1177/1941738114546846
- Warne JP, Gruber AH. Transitioning to minimal footwear: a systematic review of methods and future clinical recommendations. Sports Med Open. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-017-0096-x
- Knapik JJ, Orr R, Pope R. Update on minimalist running shoes. 2021. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34529816/
- Sánchez-Del Río E, Galán-Arriero I, Palomo-Fernández I, et al. Injury risk associated with the transition to minimalist footwear in runners: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Gait Posture. 2026. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2026.110614
- Kong PW, Candelaria NG, Smith DR. Running in new and worn shoes: a comparison of three types of cushioning footwear. Br J Sports Med. 2009;43:745-749. https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/43/10/745
- Cleveland Clinic. Your Guide To Picking the Best Running Shoes. 2026-03-31. https://health.clevelandclinic.org/how-to-pick-the-running-shoe-that-is-best-for-you
Written 2026-11-22 · 8 sources · Last reviewed 2026-11-22
This article is general health information, not a diagnosis. Shoe choice and training changes should be discussed with a clinician or physiotherapist if you have ongoing pain, a recent injury or a bone stress injury.

답글 남기기